Skip to content

“Hey, You Calling Me an Invasive Species?”

September 10, 2013

The New York Times published an op-ed by a member of their Editorial Board on Sunday, September 8, 2013, entitled, “Hey, You Calling Me an Invasive Species?”  It is a spirited defense of non-native plants.  Surely this is an indication that our challenge of the native plant movement is now mainstream.  We will touch on a few of the op-ed’s main themes, but we urge you to read the op-ed here.

Mount Sutro Forest is threatened with destruction because it is not native.  Courtesy Save Sutro Forest.

Mount Sutro Forest is threatened with destruction because it is not native. Courtesy Save Sutro Forest.

Using the eucalyptus forest on Mount Sutro as an example. the Editorial Board member, Verlyn Klinkenborg, makes the point that many of our non-native plants have been here for hundreds of years.  Since they have been here for several generations of humans, most of us no longer consider them foreigners: 

“But the trees on Mount Sutro have been there within the memory of every living San Franciscan, and to the generations who have grown up within view of them, it seems almost perverse to insist that they are alien.” 

The distinction between native and non-native depends upon an arbitrarily selected “snapshot” of our landscape taken just prior to the arrival of Europeans.  On the East Coast, that’s the early 16th Century.  In the San Francisco Bay Area, that’s 1769, when Portola’s men saw the San Francisco Bay.  The Times op-ed reminds us that this particular snapshot is becoming more and more irrelevant because of climate change.  If plants and animals don’t move in response to that change they will not survive: 

“As plants and their pests adjust their range under the influence of global warming, what becomes of the distinction between native and nonnative?  To any individual species, it doesn’t matter whether it’s native or not.  The only thing that matters is whether its habitat is suitable.”

Finally, Mr. Klinkenborg takes us on a verbal tour of Central Park to make the point that our open spaces are a mélange of native and non-native plants and animals.  We can see with our eyes that they are living in harmony and to pluck only those considered non-native from their midst would be needlessly destructive and disruptive of the peace that reigns there:

“Nature in Central Park can’t be divided into native or nonnative species, and neither can it be on Mount Sutro.  The eucalyptus trees that grow there may be naturalized rather than native, but try telling that to all the other creatures that live in those woods or the people who hike there.”

Mr. Klinkenborg’s final sentence reminds us that we are the original “invaders:” 

And when it comes to the distinction between native and nonnative, we always leave one species out:  call us what you will—native, naturalized, alien or invasive.”

The absurdity of nativism is becoming more and more evident.  Our objections to its destructive consequences will eventually be heard.  It’s just a matter of time.

5 Comments leave one →
  1. September 16, 2013 4:30 pm

    I wish all the “environmentalists” who recommend killing trees and other plants and animals, destroying lakes, etc. because they are not native, would read this blog.

    Non-native humans, start with your own yards and selves….

Trackbacks

  1. Scientists critique UCSF’s plans for Mount Sutro and native plant advocates react | Death of a Million Trees
  2. 2013 Progress Report | Death of a Million Trees
  3. California Invasive Plant Council‏: Remove Blue Gum Eucalyptus from the List of Invasive Plants | San Francisco Forest Alliance
  4. California Invasive Plant Council sticks to its guns aimed at eucalyptus | Death of a Million Trees

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: