Bees are harmed by nativism

As our readers know, there are many reasons why we are opposed to the projects that are billed as native plant “restorations” but, in fact, often do a great deal of damage to the environment.  Of the many bogus justifications for these harmful projects, one of the most patently false is that the projects benefit wildlife.  Today, we are publishing a letter from one of our readers about the many ways in which nativism is harmful to bees.

“I thought of you, and your ongoing fight against short-sighted nativism, yesterday as I was doing research for a project on bees. I was interviewing a second-generation beekeeper, who’s working closely with geneticists and entomologists to develop hardy strains of bees, and he mentioned two things I thought might help to highlight how the actions of groups like the NAP may actually be contributing to colony collapse:

  1. The chemicals they use. Of course, it’s been broadly publicized that glyphosate and neonicotinoids are harmful to bees, and the AG industry folks (and possibly the native plant folks?) counter that they are far less deadly to honey bees than other types of herbicides and pesticides…but the beekeeper I spoke with indicated that saying something is “less deadly” to bees misses the harm these chemicals do to colonies by weakening their ability to fight viruses, mites, etc. Bees foraging in chemical-laden fields bring residues of these compounds back to the hive, to the queen, which he likened to “placing a pregnant woman in a refinery.” The result is a dramatically shortened lifespan for the queen and a colony that’s less strong and healthy, with lower resistance to common diseases. So the chemical may not kill the bees outright, but it still contributes to their death in the end.
  2. Honeybee on oxalis flower, another non-native plant being eradicated with herbicide.
    Honeybee on oxalis flower, another non-native plant being eradicated with herbicide.

    Honey bees are not native to America; they’re European. And the push to eradicate non-native “weeds” has decimated their forage…essentially starving them out. He cited the case of yellow star thistle, which, he said, may have come over from Europe in the wool of sheep. Highly invasive, it used to be everywhere in CA, and it was an important source of nectar and pollen for honeybees. Then, a few decades ago, the government introduced weevils to control the plant, in the process depriving the bees of a vital food source. Beekeepers have had to range further and further afield to find areas with adequate forage for their bees.

Bumblebee on Cotoneaster, Albany Bulb. Another target for eradication.
Bumblebee on Cotoneaster, Albany Bulb. Another target for eradication.

Of course, big agriculture (subsidized by the government) has contributed to the problem as well, by plowing up land that used to grow clover and alfalfa in favor of corn (for ethanol) and soybeans. But, for me anyway, this information about non-native bees needing non-native plants was a revelation…. a real ‘a-ha’ moment that I thought could be useful in waking up well-meaning folks who may equate “native plants” with “good for bees.”

Oh, and the beekeeper also told me that one third of the food Americans eat is pollinated by honey bees….are we willing to reduce our food supply by 1/3 for the sake of “restoring” a landscape native to a time when agriculture was not prominent in California?”

The value of yellow star-thistle to bees is but one example of the value of non-native plants to insects and other animals.  In the case of bees, the eradication of hundreds of thousands of eucalyptus trees all over California has deprived bees and hummingbirds of one of the few sources of winter nectar in California.  Eucalyptus blooms from December to May, at a time when there are few other sources of nectar.  HERE is an article about the loss of this important resource to bee keepers in California.

Eucalyptus and bee. Painting by Brian Stewart.
Eucalyptus and bee. Painting by Brian Stewart.

Yellow star-thistle is one of many eradication targets of nativists in California.  East Bay Regional Park District (EBRPD) has been trying to eradicate it in their parks for decades.  We recently learned that EBRPD was planning an aerial spraying of herbicide from a helicopter on 200 acres of yellow star thistle in Briones Park.   This was a particularly controversial herbicide application for several reasons:

  • Briones Park is adjacent to the watershed surrounding Briones Reservoir, which stores the drinking water of surrounding communities.briones_450w_32c
  • The herbicide EBRPD was planning to use was Milestone, which is known to be very mobile and persistent in the soil. For that reason, the State of New York refused to approve the sale of Milestone because they were concerned about contamination of ground water.
  • Aerial spraying of pesticides by helicopter is the most dangerous application method because it greatly increases the chances of drift into non-target areas, including residential areas.

Our team of collaborators jumped into action to prevent this spraying from being done.  We organized a telephone and email campaign directed to responsible staff and Board members at both East Bay Regional Park District and East Bay Municipal Water District, which is responsible for drinking water in the East Bay.

I am pleased to report that EBRPD announced within a few days of our campaign that they were permanently cancelling this aerial application of herbicides at Briones Park.  They will continue to try to eradicate yellow star thistle using other methods.

Lessons learned

When pesticides are used in native plant “restorations,” the claim that such projects are beneficial seem utterly dishonest.  Beneficial to whom?  Certainly not the animals and humans who are exposed to these toxic chemicals.

If the public does not want public land managers to use pesticides on our public lands, we must object when they do.  If we don’t object, we get the land management we deserve.  You will be alerted to such opportunities to participate in these campaigns to influence land managers by “liking” Facebook pages:  “Death of a Million Trees” and “Save the East Bay Hills.”

It is a team effort to learn about what is happening in our public lands and to participate in the decisions that affect our communities.  We are therefore grateful to the reader who shared her conversation with a beekeeper.  We encourage others to share their knowledge so that we can be as effective as possible.  Knowledge is power!

2 thoughts on “Bees are harmed by nativism”

  1. Thank you for another wonderful post!

    Honeybees show the hypocrisy of the nativists more than almost anything else. All non-native animals should be killed or eliminated (except for them)? But what about honeybees who are native to Europe? Of course nativists want them because of how important they are in pollinating the non-native plants that the nativists love to eat.

    I’ve been noticing in the Bay Area bird groups on facebook that so many of the spectacular photos of nesting and roosting birds show them in Eucalyptus. It’s not just raptors and hummmingbirds who need them. They are ideal with their height, open canopy, and sweet flowers.

    1. I am sorry to say that not all nativists are willing to give honeybees a free pass. The Nature Conservancy is eradicating honeybees on their properties on the Channel Island, one of the most extreme “restorations” ever attempted.

      More recently, I read a story in the High Country News about honeybees being evicted from federal properties based on the claim that they are spreading disease to native bees. The study cited for that claim looked suspicious to me. When honeybees are evicted from open spaces their nectar sources are reduced and their ability to survive is threatened, as the letter from our reader says.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: