The feel-good ending of the local news broadcast on Channel 7 (ABC) on February 17, 2021, featured this video of a huge field of oxalis (Bermuda buttercup, Oxalis pes-caprae) blooming on the roadside of Highway 1 in Santa Cruz County. People were stopping along the road to admire the bright yellow blooms of spring and photograph them. No one said anything about where the plant “belongs,” and no bad words were spoken about this useful plant that native plant advocates love to hate.
Despite its beauty and utility, oxalis is sprayed with one of the most toxic herbicides on the market in public parks and open spaces in the Bay Area. San Francisco’s Recreation and Parks Department has been spraying oxalis in several public parks for over 15 years. San Francisco Forest Alliance (SFFA) published a brilliant article about this pointless and destructive crusade that was republished by Conservation Sense and Nonsense in 2015. That article about the many benefits of oxalis is one of the most popular articles on this blog; it has been viewed by over 10,000 readers and many more on the SFFA website. We invite you to visit it and we summarize it briefly here:
- Oxalis blooms briefly in early spring and dies back before summer begins, leaving the ground to other plants. It does not kill other plants, rather it co-exists briefly during its annual bloom.
- Oxalis is very useful to pollinators and its tuberous roots (bulbils) are eaten by ground dwelling animals such as gophers.
- Oxalis is called sour-grass because of its pleasant-tasting tang and it is often eaten by children.
- Triclopyr is the active ingredient in the herbicide that is used on oxalis during its blooming season. It damages the soil by killing beneficial fungi and microbes, and it is toxic to many animals.
The annual poisoning of oxalis on Mount Davidson was recently videotaped by Ron Proctor and published by the San Francisco Forest Alliance. A crew of 5 men was hired to do the deed. Ironically, this spraying of oxalis on Mount Davidson in San Francisco was taking place at the same time that tourists were admiring oxalis in a neighboring county.
Oxalis is not an isolated example of a non-native plant that is admired by the public, but hated by native plant advocates and public land managers who do their bidding. As a member of the Sierra Club, I receive emails alerting me to opportunities to advocate for the protection of the environment. The most recent email featured a picture of a yellow wildflower in the foreground of a photograph of a Bay Area landscape:
The yellow wildflower in the foreground is Black Mustard (Brassica nigra). I responded to the Sierra Club’s email:
“The plant in the foreground of your photograph appears to be Brassica nigra: ‘Brassica nigra, or black mustard, is an annual plant cultivated for its black or dark brown seeds, which are commonly used as a spice. It is native to tropical regions of North Africa, temperate regions of Europe, and parts of Asia.’ Wikipedia
“I hope the use of this photo in this Sierra Club email to its members means that the Sierra Club is finally prepared to accept the reality of the presence of non-native plants in our public parks and open spaces. The Sierra Club’s support for unnecessary and destructive eradication projects has been regrettable, particularly because they require the use of harmful herbicides. I hope this email is an indication that the Sierra Club is finally ready to reconsider this futile crusade.”
I received this disappointing reply from the Sierra Club: “The staffer who puts together our newsletter isn’t a plant buff and wouldn’t have known the difference. But I am a plant buff and review the newsletter and know the difference between a mustard and a native plant. I somehow just overlooked that photo entirely. Thanks for bringing it to my attention. I’ll be more careful in my review of the newsletter in the future (look more carefully at the photos). And we’ll change the online version.”
The beauty and resilience of weeds
The Bottom Line
The general public doesn’t care where plants came from. The public recognizes and values beauty wherever it is found. Unfortunately, our public lands are in the death grip of the native plant movement and environmental organizations that should be objecting to the use of herbicides in our public parks and not promoting that destructive agenda. The crusade against non-native plants has been responsible for spraying our public lands with dangerous pesticides for over 20 years. They have little to show for their toxic crusade, perhaps because the herbicides damage the soil and make the survival of native plants even less likely.
The featured photo at the top of this article was taken in Glen Canyon, another public park in San Francisco where oxalis has been sprayed annually for many years. The copyright photo of a coyote in a field of oxalis was taken by Janet Kessler and is shown with her permission.
7 thoughts on “Nobody cares where a pretty wildflower is from”
It is worth noting, the 5 men spraying on Mt Davidson were not hired just for this job. SF RPD has 5 full time herbicide “technicians” who report directly to Lisa Wayne, the head of their Natural Resources Division. When they are not dosing Mt Davidson with chemicals, they are off polluting some other park.
I read an article in the Sonoma county native plant newsletter maybe seven years back, where the writer, ML, said people were telling her that the Native Plant Society is a hate group. She ended the article by saying that when she sees a “non-native” plant, and she can’t immediately kill it, she would at least injure it. I quit the native plant society after reading her article. This was before the rise of Trump and the xenophobic mania he encouraged. Nazi Germany also encouraged the xenophobic killing of “non-native” plants. But the thing is that all life migrates constantly, or stagnates without fresh genes. Sonia Shah’s book on migration documents this beautifully.
On Mon, Feb 22, 2021 at 5:05 AM Conservation Sense and Nonsense wrote:
> milliontrees posted: “The feel-good ending of the local news broadcast on > Channel 7 (ABC) on February 17, 2021, featured this video of a huge field > of oxalis (Bermuda buttercup, Oxalis pes-caprae) blooming on the roadside > of Highway 1 in Santa Cruz County. People were stoppin” >
That is consistent with my experience. I remember my first encounter with eucalyptus hatred was a “Perspective” on KQED radio that began with the sentence, “I hate eucalyptus.” I sent an email to KQED that began, “Any sentence that begins with ‘I hate,’ is bound to end badly and this listener’s “Perspective” is not an exception to that rule.” I wonder where people find the energy to hate anything, let alone an innocent plant that did not choose to be moved around the planet. Thanks, Marigold.
Thank you for this fantastic—beautifully rendered and convincing —article. I sent a copy to KPFA. I continue to monitor their various shows pro-nativist stance and for over a decade.
Onward comrades! Ariane
That is indeed a lovely article. Thanks! Rupa, webmaster of Save Sutro Forest
Thank you for this lovely article. I love oxalis so much, for so many reason. Whenever I read/hear about poison spraying, I wonder how many more will suffer and die as a result. Something is very wrong when anyone wants to kill such a beautiful plant.
I agree that the nativists are a hate group. Even when it’s illegal, they advise people to kill plants in our parks.